Why does the water only show up when it warms up?
Ice both splits the pipe and plugs it. While the plug holds, nothing escapes. As soon as the line thaws, full house pressure comes through the new opening, so the leak starts at the moment the weather improves and the house is least on guard.
This is why a dead tap during a cold spell is worth acting on immediately. The useful move is to close the main and open a low fixture, which takes the pressure out of the system before the thaw arrives. A household that does that may still need a plumber, but it will not need a drying crew.
Which pipes freeze first in a Birmingham house?
The ones in spaces that are not heated and not meant to be: crawl spaces open to outside air, attics above the insulation, garages, and runs in exterior walls. An outside spigot with a hose still attached is the most reliable failure of the lot.
Plumbing in a climate of occasional freezes tends to be routed for convenience rather than for cold, and that is not a criticism of anyone's house, it is a description of a reasonable choice. The practical consequence is that a freeze finds whichever run is most exposed, and in a pier-built house that is almost always the one under the floor. Where supply lines cross an attic to reach an upstairs bathroom, that run is the other candidate.
How do you keep this from happening next time?
Disconnect hoses from outdoor spigots, insulate exposed runs in crawl spaces, garages and attics, keep crawl space access closed during a cold spell, and leave a trickle running at the fixture farthest along the most exposed line. Know where your main shut-off is.
Moving water freezes less readily than still water, which is why a trickle at the most exposed tap helps, and opening cabinet doors under a sink on an outside wall lets house air reach the pipes behind it. For a house that will stand empty through cold weather, the better answer is to close the main and drain the system rather than to rely on a thermostat. Not one of these measures needs a contractor; all of them are cheaper than this page.
What decides the size of the bill after a freeze?
How long the split ran once it thawed, how many rooms and levels the water crossed, whether insulation and ceiling board have to come out, access to the space the pipe sits in, and how many days of equipment the readings call for. The scope is priced and approved before work starts.
A break that emptied into a crawl space for an hour and one that ran through a ceiling all afternoon are different jobs, even though the same length of pipe failed. Access matters more than people expect: a line under a low crawl space or above a finished ceiling takes time to reach and to dry. Because the weather after a freeze here is often damp, drying can run longer than it would in a dry climate, as our guide on drying a house in humid Alabama summers explains. No figures are published on this site; a written scope you approve comes first.
Should you thaw a frozen pipe yourself?
Never with a flame, a propane torch or a heat gun. Those start fires in wall cavities and crawl spaces, and they can burst a pipe that was going to survive. Warm the room, not the pipe, and close the main first so a split has nothing to deliver.
If you can reach an exposed frozen section safely, gentle warmth from a room heater placed well away from anything combustible, or warm cloths on the pipe, is the limit of sensible self-help. Work from the fixture end toward the frozen part so meltwater has somewhere to go. If the line is inside a wall, in an attic or under the floor, leave it: a plumber can reach it without opening three feet of ceiling, and a restoration crew can dry what the thaw wets.